Wednesday, December 07, 2011

The Tyranny of the Minority

By Moshe Feiglin

11 Kislev, 5772
Dec. 7,' 11

Translated from Ma'ariv's NRG website

"This is not the good-old Likud that we know," sighed the party's veteran "princes."
"Where is Begin's liberalism?" cried the journalists. "Where is the Jabotinsky splendor?" "We must guard against the tyranny of the majority." "Democracy is in danger!" "A murky wave threatens Israel's democracy!" "A dark Feiglinite dictatorship."

If you listen to the cries of despair over the latest legislative proposals emanating from Israel's media, (editor's note: Proposed are an increase in the fine for slander and required hearings for judicial candidates for the Supreme Court) you may mistakenly think that Israel has suffered a military putsch. Perhaps Pinochet has returned from the dead and taken over the Knesset? But in truth, the new legislation is not a threat to democracy, but rather, a brave attempt to save it.

Yitzchak Rabin's leftist government rammed the Oslo Accords through the Knesset with a miniscule majority; they simply promised ex-MK Alex Goldfarb a new Mitsubishi and the deal was done. The Oslo Accords destroyed thousands of lives and threw the State of Israel into a suicidal process from which it has yet to extricate itself. Nobody in the media talked then about the tyranny of the majority. On the contrary; instead of fulfilling their intended role as the watchdog of democracy, the media turned themselves into democracy's attack dogs.

Ariel Sharon garnered the majority that he needed to expel the 10,000 residents of Gush Katif by firing the government ministers who opposed the expulsion. He received the Supreme Court's endorsement of his "democratic" majority and the media declaratively treated Sharon with kid gloves. All his misdeeds were put on hold as long as he was carrying out the much-anticipated expulsion and destruction. We all know the price: Missiles fired from the ruins of Gush Katif straight into Be'er Sheva. Nobody then deplored the tyranny of the fictitious majority. Dan Meridor even came to Kedumim and to my astonishment, explained to the people there that the expulsion was an expression of democracy and that they must cooperate with it.

Is there nothing worse than the tyranny of the majority? I can think of at least one thing: the tyranny of the minority.

The princes are right. This is not the good-old Likud. It is much better. It is a Likud that is finally beginning to express the Jabotinsky spirit of liberty. It is a Likud that dares to rule simply because it was elected by the majority of Israelis to implement nationalist policies and not leftist policies.

It is no coincidence that most of the legislative proposals of the new, excellent Likud MKs are aimed at the courts and the media. These two systems are not elected by the public. They express a blatantly anti-nationalist agenda and represent the opinion of the minority in Israel. These systems are accustomed to controlling Israeli society, fashioning the public agenda as per the worldview of the shrinking minority and keeping Israel's elected officials on a tightrope.

This small clique has engineered the Israeli public space so that when the voter votes Left, he gets Left, and when he votes Right, he also gets Left. This tyranny, this inability of the Jewish/nationalist/rightist/traditional majority to express itself through democratic elections is poised to be rectified by the super-democratic new legislative proposals. That is the source of the Left's heart-rending cries. Those who have gotten used to ruling without elections have suddenly realized that the party is just about over, and they are firing all their cannons.

"The Silencing Law," they call the legislation that if passed, will prevent slander against innocent people. A newspaper has money and high-powered lawyers and can write whatever it wants about an individual. Most people cannot prove that the slander harmed them, and who can fight a long court battle against the all-powerful media? The apology, if it comes, is written in two tiny rows somewhere in the back of the paper, a pitiful contra to the screaming headlines and huge pictures from the front page.

The "watchdogs" are not guarding democracy. They are guarding themselves, making sure that you will not hear what they do not want you to hear, ensuring that you will not think for yourself. They call the law that is supposed to protect the citizens from slander "The Silencing Law." How Orwellian. The proposed legislation explicitly states that if the report is true, the media source is not liable for damages. But they want the right to slander, not the right to expose the truth.

I salute MKs Yariv Levin, Ze'ev Elkin, Danny Danon and the entire new generation that has grown up in the Likud. You are the Likud's real princes. In your merit, Jabotinsky can start to smile. Don't give up. Through your efforts, Israel may even enjoy a real democracy.

No comments: